ScienceHistoryStorytelling

Scientific Claims Courtroom

Grades 6-890-120 minSource: Creative Dad Company

Students put a real (or realistic) science claim on trial. First they repeat the experiment behind it themselves, then they argue whether the evidence really supports the headline. It is a great cure for believing every headline that says studies show something.

Budget levels

Amazon prices checked Oct 9-10, 2026 and may change

Materials links go to Amazon. Prices are estimates and may change. As an Amazon Associate, Creative Dad Company earns from qualifying purchases.

Quick Start

Digital downloads only.

$0 to buy. Printing noted separately.

Student time: one class period, one day.

Teacher prep / build-ahead: separate from student time.

Scale it

The default plan is one class period on a single day.

Scale back: Fit it into a shorter period, use fewer effects, or run a demo instead of a build.

Scale up: Add one extra effect, or spread the share-out across another day.

Ambiance video

Ambiance video coming soon from Creative Dad Studio

clear cupsBorrow or school hasuse what you have
kitchen scaleBorrow or school hasuse what you have
timerBorrow or school hasuse what you have

Full Experience

Required materials for the class.

$48.96 per class (class of about 30, 6 groups). Exceeds $25 per class.

Classroom cardboard or boxes can lower the cost.

Student time: one day.

Teacher prep / build-ahead: separate from student time.

Scale it

The default plan is one school day.

Scale back: Fit the build into one period with fewer effects.

Scale up: Spread the work across days, or add more effects.

Digital thermometersRequired2 x 5 thermometers5 thermometers$9.99Amazon
clamp lampRequired1 x 1 light1 light$18.99Amazon
sandRequired1 x 2.88 lb2.88 lb$9.99Amazon

Total Transformation

The bigger kit, with every optional item included.

$48.96 per class (class of about 30, 6 groups).

Student time: one day (one session, one-day event).

Teacher prep / build-ahead: separate from student time.

Scale it

The default plan is one session, a one-day event.

Scale back: Shorten the event, or run a demo for a smaller audience.

Scale up: Spread the build and the event across days, or invite a bigger audience.

Materials

Simplified version of a real science claim (teacher-prepared); Materials to repeat the experiment (depend on the claim); Digital thermometers; clamp lamp; sand; clear cups; kitchen scale; timer

Materials links go to Amazon. Prices are estimates and may change.

As an Amazon Associate, Creative Dad Company earns from qualifying purchases.

Kitchen scale
kitchen scale
Shop
Materials to repeat the experiment
Materials to repeat the experiment (depend on the claim)
No link

Steps

Read a simplified headline claim: 'Study shows sand heats up faster than water.' Predict whether it will hold up and what else might matter, like how much of each you have.
Plan an investigation: the variables (type of matter, mass, energy transferred measured as minutes under the same lamp) and the measured result (temperature change). List controls such as same cup, same lamp distance, and same starting temperature.
Test 1, type of matter: equal masses of sand and water under the lamp for 10 minutes. Record temperature every 2 minutes.
Test 2, mass: 100 g versus 200 g of water under the same lamp for 10 minutes.
Test 3, energy transferred: the same sample heated for 5 versus 10 minutes.
Graph temperature change for each test and explain using particles: a bigger temperature rise means faster average particle motion, and different materials and masses need different amounts of energy for the same rise.
Hold a mock trial where prosecution and defense argue whether the headline is valid, using your data as evidence.

Standards mapped

NGSS · MS-PS3-4
Plan an investigation to determine the relationships among the energy transferred, the type of matter, the mass, and the change in the average kinetic energy of the particles as measured by the temperature of the sample.